CM Murad orders strict accountability over KulsumBai Valika Hospital HIV crisis

Sindh Chief Minister Syed Murad Ali Shah on Monday directed the Labour Department to ensure strict accountability, uninterrupted treatment, and long-term rehabilitation of children affected by the HIV outbreak at KulsumBai Valika Hospital, declaring that negligence in healthcare delivery would not be tolerated under any circumstances

KARACHI, (APP - UrduPoint / Pakistan Point News - 13th Jul, 2026) Sindh Chief Minister Syed Murad Ali Shah on Monday directed the Labour Department to ensure strict accountability, uninterrupted treatment, and long-term rehabilitation of children affected by the HIV outbreak at KulsumBai Valika Hospital, declaring that negligence in healthcare delivery would not be tolerated under any circumstances.

Presiding over a high-level meeting at the CM House to review the HIV cases detected at the Sindh Employees’ Social Security Institution (SESSI)-run KulsumBai Valika Hospital, the chief minister was informed that 78 children have so far been identified as HIV-positive, while disciplinary proceedings have been initiated against dozens of officials and healthcare workers following multiple inquiries into the outbreak.

The meeting was attended by Labour Minister Saeed Ghani, Chief Secretary Sindh Asif Hyder Shah, Secretary to Chief Minister Asif Jameel, Secretary Labour Sajid Jamal Abro, Secretary Health Tahir Sangi, Commissioner SESSI and other senior officials.

The chief minister was briefed that the matter first surfaced after six HIV-positive cases were reported on October 23, 2025. Subsequently, the Labour and Human Resources Department ordered an inquiry, and SESSI constituted a committee headed by its Medical Advisor to investigate the matter.

The inquiry committee, constituted by Labour Minister Saeed Ghani, inspected the hospital, particularly the Paediatrics Department and laboratory facilities, and submitted its report on November 6, 2025. The report identified 16 HIV-positive children, all linked to the Paediatrics Department, and highlighted serious administrative, procedural and infection-control failures.

Saeed Ghani informed the meeting that the inquiry uncovered the absence of standard operating procedures, inadequate supervision of sterilisation practices, improper biomedical waste disposal, shortage of biohazard containers, weak inventory controls, insufficient supply of disposable medical items, poor documentation, inadequate HIV testing facilities, and failure to conduct structured follow-up of HIV-positive patients and their families.

The committee also noted instances where single-use medical equipment, including syringes, may have been improperly handled, while healthcare staff were not consistently adhering to infection-prevention protocols and personal protective equipment requirements.

The chief minister was further informed that concerns over the outbreak intensified after complaints were received from affected families and the SITE Association of Trade and Industry, which alleged serious lapses in infection-control practices at the hospital.

Saeed Ghani told the CM, following the inquiry, SESSI initiated a series of corrective measures, including the establishment of an Anti-Retroviral Therapy (ART) Centre at KulsumBai Valika Hospital. The ART Centre was established on November 15, 2025 and became fully operational on November 24, 2025, after specialised training was conducted by the Communicable Disease Control (CDC) programme of the Sindh Health Department.

The meeting was told that HIV prevention protocols and standard operating procedures were subsequently developed and circulated to all SESSI healthcare facilities across Sindh. Screening of more than 300 doctors and paramedical staff was also conducted, resulting in the identification of two HIV-positive employees, whose family members later tested negative.

Labour Minister briefed the chief minister that disciplinary proceedings were initiated against the then Medical Superintendent and nine other officers and officials in December 2025. Following unsatisfactory responses to show-cause notices, further action was taken in February 2026.

<?php /*?> <?php */?>

The meeting was informed that the Provincial Ombudsman (Mohtasib) Sindh took suo motu notice of the matter and issued several directives, including the transfer of the then Medical Superintendent, establishment of a dedicated isolation ward, a comprehensive inquiry, a third-party audit of hospital operations, and provision of the best available treatment to all affected children at government expense.

In compliance with these directions, an isolation ward for HIV-positive children was established, routine HIV screening was initiated for all OPD and admitted patients, and a special audit was ordered to examine procurement, inventory management and budget utilisation.

The chief minister was informed that a second comprehensive inquiry committee, headed by Chief Medical Officer Dr Naila Zaheer, submitted its report on June 19, 2026. The committee fixed responsibility on a number of officers and officials for administrative, supervisory and operational lapses and recommended major and minor penalties.

As a result, 37 officers and officials, including former and serving administrators, doctors, nurses, laboratory personnel and support staff, have been suspended. Show-cause notices were issued to all of them on July 3, 2026, with directions to submit their replies within 14 days.

The meeting was also informed that a constitutional petition concerning the matter is currently pending before the Sindh High Court, while comments have been sought from the authorities.

Saeed Ghani told the chief minister that renowned paediatric infectious disease specialist Prof Dr Fatima Mir of Aga Khan University Hospital has been engaged to provide specialised consultation and treatment for HIV-positive children suffering from associated infections. Families of affected children are also being contacted and linked with treatment centres to ensure continuity of care.

The CM said that he has created a Rs 2 billion Endowment Fund to support the treatment, welfare, rehabilitation and long-term care of HIV-positive children and their families.

Speaking on the occasion, CM Shah expressed deep concern over the findings of the inquiries and emphasised that the government would pursue complete accountability wherever negligence or misconduct was established.

“The lives of children are sacred. Any lapse in medical protocols that endangers patients is unacceptable and will be dealt with strictly in accordance with the law,” the chief minister said.

CM Shah directed the Labour Department, Health Department and SESSI administration to ensure that all affected children receive uninterrupted treatment, medicines, diagnostic services and follow-up care free of cost. Every child must receive the best available treatment, counselling and rehabilitation support without financial burden,” he said.

The chief minister also ordered a province-wide review of infection-control practices in all SESSI healthcare facilities and directed that strict compliance with sterilisation, waste management and patient-safety protocols be ensured. “This incident must serve as a turning point for strengthening patient safety standards across our healthcare system. Preventive mechanisms, monitoring systems and accountability frameworks must be institutionalised to ensure such an incident never occurs again,” he directed.

Murad Shah further instructed authorities to complete departmental proceedings against responsible officials on merit and without delay, finalise the third-party audit, strengthen surveillance mechanisms, and submit periodic progress reports on treatment, rehabilitation and institutional reforms.